Miseall ingredients
substitutes

Pumpkin Pie Spice substitutes

Out of pumpkin pie spice? These are its closest flavor matches, ranked by Epicure's flavor-compound model — the percentage is how near each sits to pumpkin pie spice in flavor space. Maple Syrup is closest at 49%.

  1. 01
    Maple Syrup
    49% flavor match
  2. 02
    Eggnog
    47% flavor match
  3. 03
    Brown Sugar
    47% flavor match
  4. 04
    Egg Substitute
    47% flavor match
  5. 05
    Baking Soda
    47% flavor match
  6. 06
    Apple Pie Spice
    46% flavor match

Cooking with pumpkin pie spice?

Paste your recipe into Mise — we'll find every ingredient as a real product you can buy, and swap the ones you can't, like pumpkin pie spice, for the closest match in stock.

Turn a recipe into a basket →

How we choose these

Each match is the nearest neighbour to pumpkin pie spice in Epicure, a food-science model mapping the aroma compounds of ~1,790 ingredients across 4 million recipes. The percentage is their flavor-space similarity. Taste as you go — substitutes shift texture and intensity too.

Flavor data: Epicure (Radzikowski & Chen, 2026), arXiv:2605.22391, CC-BY-4.0.